The fate of mantle-derived carbon in a continental sedimentary basin: Integration of C/He relationships and stable isotope signatures

Sherwood Lollar B, Ballentine CJ, O'Nions RK

The isotopic composition and abundances of the rare gases (He, Ne, and Ar) and active gases (CO2, CH4) have been determined in a series of commercial gas reservoirs in the Pannonian and Vienna basins of Hungary and Austria, respectively. In these zones of continental extension, significant components of mantle-derived 4He (up to 39.8%) and 21Ne (up to 58%) are identified. The results of this study indicate a major component of mantle-derived carbon in these systems as well. Ranging in composition from close to 100% CO2, to CH4-dominated reservoirs with trace concentrations (ppm) of CO2, these gas reservoirs provide a unique opportunity to examine the relationship of the conservative rare gases to the active gas components and to examine the sources and sinks for mantle- and crustal-derived carbon phases. With the exception of Kismarja gas field (which shows evidence of addition of 3He-depleted crustal CO2), all gas fields exhibit a trend whereby the most CO2-rich samples approach CO2/3Hemntl values similar to MORB (2 × 109 to 7 × 109), while CO2-depleted samples extend to CO2/3Hemntl values as low as 105. The lack of any correlation of CO2/3Hemntl ratios with R/Ra values indicates the observed trends are not a function of mixing between crustal- and mantle-derived endmembers, but instead reflect progressive loss of the mantle-derived CO2 carrier phase during volatile transport and emplacement in the continental crust. Based on stable isotopic signatures from the Kismarja field, a crustal CO2 endmember with an isotopic composition of -6.8‰ and a mantle CO2 endmember with an isotopic composition no more depleted in 13C than -5.0‰ can be identified, one of the few instances where the isotopic signatures of mantle-and crustal-derived CO2 can be reliably distinguished in a continental setting. Covariation in δ 13CCO2, and δ 13CCH4 values in the gas fields is used to place constraints on two alternative models whereby the trends in percent CO2 and CO2/3Hemntl ratios can be accounted for by (1) loss of the mantle-derived CO2 carrier phase; (2) addition of crustal-derived CO2; (3) addition of crustal-derived (thermogenic) CH4; and potentially (4) conversion of the CO2mntl carrier phase to mantle-derived CH4. Based on an estimated total mantle 4He flux for the Pannonian Basin of 4.2 × 108 atoms m-2 s-1, mantle carbon flux estimates for this basin alone range from 3 × 108 g C/yr to 1 × 109 g C/yr, which over the lifetime of the basin is only 4-5 orders of magnitude less than flux estimates based on the total area of the spreading ridges. Clearly the addition of mantle-derived carbon to the crust in areas of continental extension is significant and may have been previously underestimated. We demonstrate here that integration of δ 13C data with rare gas isotopic tracers provides an important tool in constraining models of mantle carbon sources and sinks in continental settings. Copyright © 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd.