The olivine-clinopyroxene (Fe-Mg partition) geothermometer of Powell and Powell (1974) was derived on the basis of clinopyroxene mixing parameters which imply a large miscibility gap in CaFeSi2O6-CaMgSi2O6-CaAl2SiO6 clinopyroxenes at 950° C. Application of the Powell and Powell thermometer in an empirical way (ignoring likely errors in mixing parameters) is limited by the fact that almost all natural clinopyroxene-olivine pairs are constrained by the form of the equation to have 1-bar temperatures within the narrow (915-1,060° C) limits of their calibration points. Temperatures obtained from the Powell and Powell thermometer have been compared with those obtained from clinopyroxene-orthopyroxene (miscibility gap) thermometers; agreement with the latter is poor. There are discrepancies between calculated and observed (experimental) temperatures for iron-rich clinopyroxene-olivine pairs. It is concluded that application of the thermometer in its present form is unlikely to produce reliable results. © 1976 Springer-Verlag.
