Eruption Loading: New Approaches to Earthquake Monitoring at Ontake Volcano, Japan

Ontake Volcano covered with snow. Image Credit: Dr. Shinichiro Horikawa

A recent study led by Professor Mike Kendall has investigated the use of a seismic signal from volcanoes to provide an early warning of impending eruptions. The research team compared shear-wave splitting during two eruptions of Ontake Volcano in Japan, one small and one explosive, and identified that the changes to this parameter were more pronounced for the larger eruption. The study, published in Seismica, proposes that the monitoring of this signal would provide a useful early warning of dangerous volcanic eruptions.

Predicting Volcanic Eruptions

For communities living in the shadow of a volcano, early warning systems are a life line – but mistrust in these warnings can have deadly consequences. To avoid false alarms, it is vital that scientists seek more reliable ways to monitor volcanoes.

A new study from Oxford Earth Sciences has investigated a seismic signal known as shear-wave splitting for providing scientists and communities with an essential early warning of a dangerous eruption. Large movements of magma and rock inside a volcano causes seismic waves to be released, but these signals can be challenging to untangle. The goal of this research was to seek a useable parameter which could not only predict if an eruption was set to occur – but also if the eruption was going to be particularly damaging.

Shear-Wave Splitting

Shear-wave splitting is a phenomenon where seismic shear-waves waves travel at different speeds depending on their polarisation. Cracks and fractures inside the rock can slow down seismic waves, but have a larger delaying effect on seismic waves that travel across the cracks and fractures. If the cracks are aligned in one direction, then the amount of shear-wave splitting increases.

Magma and fluids moving beneath a volcano exert stresses on the surrounding rocks, causing cracks to open in certain orientations and close in others. Examining changes to shear-wave splitting through time can be really useful for scientists, as it tells them where these cracks are opening and closing. But the research team wanted to take this a step further – and test whether the larger stress changes during an explosive eruption also caused a more significant change to the amount of shear-wave splitting.

“Seismic anisotropy – or the effect of rock composition and internal fractures on the speed of shear-waves oscillating at right angles to each other – is a well-documented phenomenon. When we reflected on how anisotropy increases as the pressure inside a volcano builds, we were excited to explore if we could detect these changes, and if this could be a distinctive signal which could be applied to early warning systems.”

-  Lead Author Professor Mike Kendall (Oxford Earth Sciences)

Aerial view of Ontake Volcano, Honshū Island, Japan. Image Credit: Dr. Koshun Yamaoka

Observations at Ontake Volcano

The research team put this theory to the test by examining seismic signals during two eruptions of Ontake Volcano, on Honshū Island in Japan. The 2007 eruption was small and had much less of an impact on the surrounding community, whereas the 2014 eruption was larger, more explosive, and sadly more deadly.

They were excited to discover that during the smaller eruption, the amount of shear-wave splitting remained constant throughout, but during the larger eruption the amount of splitting doubled just before Ontake exploded. The team believe that the larger stress change during the 2014 eruption increased the observed shear-wave splitting, indicating a useful relationship between the amount of splitting and the size of the eruption.

Co-author Professor Toshiko Terakawa (Nagoya University) noted “The focal mechanisms of volcano-tectonic earthquakes changed drastically before and after the 2014 eruption. Integrating data from shear-wave splitting and earthquake focal mechanisms could provide deeper insights into conditions required for an eruption to occur.”

“The records around two eruptions on Ontake volcano in Japan have been able to show that the method can not only show changes before eruptions, but that they can potentially help to predict the size of an eruption." added co-author Professor Martha Savage (Victoria University of Wellington). "This work was an example of how cooperation among people from around the globe can address important societal problems.”

A Valuable Early Warning System

Because the change in shear-wave splitting occurred before the eruption of Ontake began, scientists monitoring the volcano will be able to use this parameter as both a vital early-warning system and an indicator of how damaging the eruption could be. This offers a new way to protect local communities from the devastating impacts of a volcanic eruption.

“We expect to see these effects at other volcanoes across the globe, not just at Ontake Volcano. As changes in volcanic stress occur prior to an eruption, we anticipate that we would see changes in shear-wave splitting. This could be a valuable tool for early warning of volcanic eruptions, especially for local communities.”

- Co-author Dr Tom Kettlety (Oxford Earth Sciences)

The study, Changes in seismic anisotropy at Ontake volcano: a tale of two eruptions, is available to read online at https://doi.org/10.26443/seismica.v4i1.1101. The research is published in Seismica, a community-driven, Diamond Open Access journal publishing peer-reviewed research in seismology and earthquake science — free to read and free to publish. The research was conducted by a team of researchers from the University of Oxford, Nagoya University, Victoria University of Wellington, University of Bristol, Kyoto University and NORSAR.

Header image credit: Dr. Shinichiro Horikawa